Simon Grant McKenzie/McKay, an AI Generated Narrative.

 If you read my previous post on Simon Grant, you will know that I have the assignment to Chat GPT to turn it into a 600 word narrative.

This is the prompt I used.

As a family historian write a narrative of 600 words on Simon McKenzie/McKay suitable for a blog post. Only use the document supplied, do not emblish or add anything. Cite the sources where used.

This is what AI gave me back. Your comments are welcome.


Narrative

Simon McKenzie or McKay: The Story of a Scottish Exile

In 1843, fifteen-year-old Simon McKenzie, also known as McKay, was living with his mother, Margaret McKenzie, in Friars Lane, Inverness, Scotland. Court records make no mention of his father. On 9 January 1843, Simon appeared before the court alongside John McDonald, charged with three counts of stealing.[1]

The charges concerned thefts committed between November 1842 and January 1843. Their victims included Joseph Mitchell, Inspector of Highland Roads and Bridges; Alexander Munro, a spirit dealer; and James Falconer, a teacher. Among the stolen property were clothing, boots, bottles, a bagpipe chanter, two legs of mutton and a hare.[2]

Simon was apprehended while sleeping in the hayloft of Mr Mitchell’s coach house, wearing boots stolen from Alexander Munro. In his statement, he identified people to whom he and John had sold stolen goods, admitting that some proceeds had been spent on whiskey. Both were found guilty on 15 April 1843 and sentenced to eighteen months in Perth Gaol.[4][6]

Released on 21 October 1844, Simon and John were arrested again in Inverness that December. This time, they were accused of stealing a blue greatcoat, wooden snuff box and cotton gloves from Alexander Watson, a meal dealer. Found guilty, both received sentences of ten years' imprisonment in Van Diemen’s Land and were transferred to Millbank Prison to await transportation.[7]

The Millbank Prison Register described Simon as seventeen, single, and able to read and write well. His offence was recorded as “theft and poor character.”[8]

On 26 May 1846, Simon boarded the Maitland, which departed England on 29 June. After 129 days at sea, including a stop at Van Diemen’s Land, the ship reached Port Phillip on 6 November 1846.[9]

Simon was among 291 men known as Exiles, who received pardons upon arrival. Queen Victoria had approved their pardons on 10 June 1846. The Exile system involved solitary confinement, opportunities for trade training and expectations of reform.[10][11]

The Maitland Dispersal List recorded Simon’s employment arrangements as “not specified,” although the intended employment period was one year.[12]

There is a gap in Simon’s documented history between his arrival in 1846 and his marriage. On 10 January 1850, recorded as Simon Grant McKenzie or McKay, he married Ann Cameron at Kilnoorat, near Camperdown, Victoria. This is the first identified record of his use of the name Grant.[12]

Simon and Ann settled in Ballarat, where they raised a family of six children: James, Margaret, Maryann, another Maryann, William Alexander and Jessie Elizabeth. Their first daughter named Maryann drowned in 1858, aged approximately two. Simon gave his occupation as miner on several birth certificates.[13][14]

Little else has been discovered about Simon’s subsequent life. His deposition at the 1858 inquest into Maryann’s death provides one documented appearance in official records.

On 18 January 1892, Simon collapsed at his home in Sweeny Street, Ballarat East, where Ann found him. Following reports that he had complained of chest pain, an inquest was held that day by Mr G. King, J.P. The verdict was chronic pneumonia.

Simon was buried in the Presbyterian section of Ballaarat General Cemetery on 20 January 1892. His grave, in New Cemetery, Section 9A, Number 33, remains unmarked.[15]

One question remains unanswered: why did Simon adopt the name Grant? The possibility that it came from Alexander Grant, the police officer who twice arrested him, is a theory rather than an established fact. No document has yet explained his decision.

From a Scottish courtroom to a family home in Ballarat, Simon’s documented life traces the journey of a young offender transported as an Exile who later married, worked and raised a family in Victoria.


Source references

The numbered citations correspond to the references in the supplied research document.

  • [1], [2], [4] National Archives of Scotland, trial documents, AD14/43/22 (1–11).
  • [6] National Archives of Scotland, sentence document, JC26/1845/6 (4).
  • [7] National Archives of Scotland, trial documents, AS14/45/118 (9).
  • [8] Home Office Prison Records, 1770–1951, via FindMyPast.
  • [9] Claim a Convict, Maitland voyage details.
  • [10] Public Record Office Victoria, Notifications of Pardons of Exiles, VPRS 89.
  • [11] Scott Brown, The Exiles – a Different Class of Victorians, 10 March 2007.
  • [12] Maitland Dispersal List; Victorian marriage certificate 2286/1850.
  • [13] Family details supplied in the original research account.
  • [14] Victorian birth certificates 1825/1857 and 2150/1860; inquest records VPRS 24, items 1858/212 and 1892/78.
  • [15] Ballaarat General Cemetery, New Cemetery receipt book, 2750.

Editorial note: This narrative uses only the supplied document. Citations reproduce its existing references, which have not been independently verified. The original document's reference numbering contains some inconsistencies, and the marriage citation is included under [12] as it appears in the supplied notes.


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Family Friday, William Vaughan.

A -Z Blogging Challenge Theme Reveal. 2021

Total Trivia: Clothes Pegs and Coat hangers.